SaaS pricing: LTV, CAC and the break-even users nobody calculates
"We're profitable at 200 customers" is usually said by someone who has not counted payment fees, churn or the cost of replacing the customers who leave. Those three numbers decide whether growth makes money or just makes noise. Here is the arithmetic, in the order that matters.
The three numbers that decide survival
For a subscription product, almost everything reduces to three quantities per customer per month:
- Net revenue per user — price minus payment processing, not price.
- Churn — the share of customers who leave each month, and therefore how often you must refill the bucket.
- CAC — what it costs in ads, content or time to get one paying customer.
Fixed costs (hosting, tools, a salary) set the floor you must clear. Everything else is a rate: how fast money comes in, how fast it leaks out, and how much it costs to pour more in.
Start with payment fees
A payment processor takes a percentage plus a fixed amount per charge. The fixed part is what hurts small prices: it is the same $0.30 whether you charge $9 or $99.
net per user = price × (1 − fee%) − fixed fee
| Monthly price | Stripe 2.9% + $0.30 | Polar 4% + $0.40 | Lemon Squeezy 5% + $0.50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| $9 | $8.44 (93.8%) | $8.24 (91.6%) | $8.05 (89.4%) |
| $19 | $18.15 (95.5%) | $17.84 (93.9%) | $17.55 (92.4%) |
| $29 | $27.86 (96.1%) | $27.44 (94.6%) | $27.05 (93.3%) |
| $49 | $47.28 (96.5%) | $46.64 (95.2%) | $46.05 (94.0%) |
| $99 | $95.83 (96.8%) | $94.64 (95.6%) | $93.55 (94.5%) |
Headline card rates as published in 2026. Merchant-of-record providers such as Polar and Lemon Squeezy also handle sales tax and VAT — that is part of what the extra percentage buys, and it can be cheaper than doing it yourself.
At $9 a month with Stripe you keep 93.8%. At $99 you keep 96.8%. Pricing low does not just reduce revenue, it makes each payment proportionally more expensive to collect.
Churn is a leak with a price tag
If 5% of your 120 customers leave each month, that is 6 customers to replace before you grow at all. Replacing them costs the same CAC as acquiring anyone else.
| Monthly churn | Customers lost (of 120) | Replacement cost at $45 CAC | Average lifetime |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | 3.6 | $162 | 33 months |
| 5% | 6.0 | $270 | 20 months |
| 8% | 9.6 | $432 | 12.5 months |
| 12% | 14.4 | $648 | 8.3 months |
Average lifetime is simply 1 ÷ churn. At 5% it is 20 months; at 12% it is 8.3. That figure multiplies every dollar of margin you make per customer — which is why churn, not price, is usually the fastest lever.
LTV, and the CAC you can afford
LTV = net revenue per user ÷ monthly churn
payback = CAC ÷ net revenue per user (months)
Using the $29 example with Stripe: net revenue per user is $27.86, so at 5% churn LTV is $557 and a $45 CAC pays back in 1.6 months. LTV:CAC is 12.4× — comfortable. At $9 a month and 12% churn, LTV is $67 and the same $45 CAC pays back in 5.3 months with a 1.5× ratio, which is fragile.
Because LTV is finite, there is a hard ceiling on CAC: it must stay below LTV, and for real profit below LTV minus your share of fixed costs. That ceiling is exactly net revenue per user ÷ churn — at $29 and 5% churn, no customer is worth more than $557 to acquire, ever.
The break-even formula
Most break-even calculations stop at fixed costs ÷ margin. That ignores churn, and churn has a price. The honest version:
break-even users = fixed costs ÷ (net per user − churn% × CAC)
Read the denominator as "what each customer contributes after payment fees, minus what it costs to keep them from disappearing". If it is zero or negative, no number of customers helps: you lose money on every sale and the only fixes are price, churn or CAC.
Worked example: $29/month
Indie product, $29/month, 120 paying customers, 5% monthly churn, $45 CAC, Stripe fees, $350 of monthly fixed costs (hosting, database, email, domain).
| Line | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| MRR | 29 × 120 | $3,480.00 |
| Payment fees | 3,480 × 2.9% + 120 × $0.30 | −$136.92 |
| Net revenue | 3,480 − 136.92 | $3,343.08 |
| Fixed costs | given | −$350.00 |
| Churn replacement | 6 × $45 | −$270.00 |
| Net profit | 3,343.08 − 350 − 270 | $2,723.08 |
Net margin is 78.2% of MRR, LTV is $557, payback is 1.6 months, and the break-even number is 14 users:
$350 ÷ ($27.86 − 5% × $45) = $350 ÷ $25.61 = 13.7 → 14 users
Fourteen users covers the bills. But notice what happens to that number as churn rises: at 8% churn break-even is 15 users, at 12% it is 16. Break-even barely moves, because fixed costs are small. What changes is everything else — at 12% churn the lifetime halves, so the same CAC buys half as much, and your growth rate collapses unless you spend more.
What raising the price does
Same $350 of fixed costs, 5% churn, $45 CAC, Stripe fees — only the price changes:
| Monthly price | Net per user | Break-even users | Profit at 120 users |
|---|---|---|---|
| $9 | $8.44 | 57 | $393 |
| $19 | $18.15 | 23 | $1,558 |
| $29 | $27.86 | 14 | $2,723 |
| $49 | $47.28 | 8 | $5,053 |
| $99 | $95.83 | 4 | $10,879 |
Tripling the price from $9 to $29 cuts break-even users by three quarters and multiplies profit by nearly seven — with the same customers, the same product and the same support load. That asymmetry is why pricing is the highest-leverage decision in a small SaaS, and why "we'll raise prices later" usually costs a year.
Two cautions. Higher prices usually raise churn, so re-run the numbers with a worse churn assumption before you celebrate. And a price is a promise about who the product is for: $99 buyers expect a different level of onboarding than $9 buyers.
FAQ
What is a good LTV:CAC ratio?
3× is the common benchmark for small SaaS. Below 2× a small churn change puts you underwater; above 5× you may be under-investing in growth.
Why charge CAC against churned customers?
Because replacing a churned customer costs the same as acquiring a new one. Charging CAC on the replacement shows the true cost of standing still.
Are payment fees a cost or a revenue reduction?
A cost that reduces net revenue. At $29 with Stripe you keep $27.86, so a margin calculated on gross price overstates reality by about four points.
How do I lower break-even fastest?
Raise the price, then cut fixed costs, then reduce churn. Price moves fastest because the fixed fee per charge stops dominating each payment.
Model it before you commit
The SaaS margin and break-even simulator runs this model live: fees, churn, CAC, break-even users and a 12-month projection. Stripe, Polar and Lemon Squeezy presets are one click. Nothing leaves your browser.